Mizz Information

  • About
  • Contact Maggie
  • Press
  • Archives
Home » Facebook 50–Proof That Metrics Are Misguided

Facebook 50–Proof That Metrics Are Misguided

12.01.2009 by Maggie McGary // Leave a Comment

So I just saw this tweet

Naturally I clicked the link; I’m always interested when social media is “proof” of anything.

TheBigMoney.com has come up with a ranking of companies based on their social media engagment. How are they defining “engagement”? According to ZDNet, this is how BigMoney explained the selection process:

Companies had to have a minimum of 200,000 Facebook friends or fans before being considered for The Big Money Facebook 50. Qualifying brands were then assessed on whether they employ a dedicated social media staff, how long the brand has been present on Facebook, and how much money it spends on the social networking site…..

(somewhat weirdly, if you click the link they are allegedly citing from, BigMoney describes their selection process a bit differently; no mention of the dedicated staff or the amount of money the brand spends on Facebook. Puzzling.)

I personally find these selection criteria off-base. If you read this blog, you know how I feel about the whole numbers game; I think it’s BS, so a threshold of 200,000 fans to even qualify as a player? Ridiculous, IMO. But whatever. What I really don’t understand, though, is how they tie the amount of money a brand spends on Facebook with how big a player they are. Call me crazy but last time I checked Facebook was free and throwing money at a developer or ad agency as a qualifier for how well you’re using it seems 100% random to me.

The whole point of social media is that it is not dreamt up by ad agencies and shoved down our throats. Are we really going to start defining success by who can most closely replicate traditional advertising while making it look like engagement?

How about the nonprofit Facebook 50? Would success be tied to how many fans a nonprofit had, or how much money they spent on the page?

Share?

Categories // Facebook, Social media, Uncategorized

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Welcome to Mizz Information

Hi and thanks for visiting Mizz Information. Who am I and what is this blog about? Here you go.

Like what you read and want to subscribe to get updates via email? Sign up below–and thanks!

Subscribe to Mizz Information

Please check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

Search Mizz Information

Categories

Archives

© 2022 Maggie McGary ยท Site design by Modern Studio Pro